Why Tunneling Destroys the Wrong Carbide Grade
Switching a roadheader drum from sandstone to mixed-strata face conditions often results in immediate tool life collapse. The carbide tip, previously optimized for abrasion resistance, begins to chip and fracture under new impact loads. This is not a manufacturing defect; it is a predictable result of selecting a hard, brittle grade for an application demanding toughness.
Roadheader picks operate in hostile underground environments. The cutting head rotates at high speeds, striking rock with immense force. Each impact generates shock waves traveling through the carbide tip. If the grade cannot absorb this energy, it fails.
Failure is not random. It results from a mismatch between the carbide’s fracture toughness and the rock’s impact intensity. Procurement teams often focus solely on hardness (HRA), assuming harder is always better. In roadheader applications, hardness without sufficient toughness leads to catastrophic tip loss, increased downtime, and higher cost per meter advanced.
The Technical Variables That Determine Grade Performance
Selecting the correct roadheader picks carbide grade requires understanding the interplay between hardness, cobalt content, and grain size. These variables trade off against each other in a predictable manner.
Hardness (HRA) and Wear Resistance
Hardness determines resistance to abrasion. In abrasive rock like sandstone or quartzite, a high HRA value (90+) prevents the tip from wearing down quickly. High hardness often correlates with lower fracture toughness.
Cobalt Content and Toughness
Cobalt acts as the binder metal. Increasing cobalt content from 6% to 12% significantly increases flexural strength, allowing the carbide to absorb impact without cracking. Higher cobalt reduces hardness, making the material more susceptible to abrasive wear.
Grain Size and Edge Integrity
Grain size controls the microstructure. Fine grains (1–2 µm) provide a dense structure with high wear resistance but lower toughness. Coarse grains (2–3 µm) improve fracture toughness and impact resistance but may reduce edge retention in highly abrasive conditions.
For roadheader picks, impact toughness is often the limiting constraint. A tip that wears evenly is preferable to one that chips and falls out, as chipping causes sudden tool loss and potential damage to the pick body.
Grade Options and Performance Trade-offs
Ruixin offers specific grades engineered for different balances of wear and impact. The following table compares our primary grades for roadheader applications.
| Grade | Hardness (HRA) | Grain Size (µm) | Flexural Strength (MPa) | Best For | Weakness |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SR7X | 91.0 ± 0.5 | 1.0–1.2 | ≥ 2,000 | High-abrasion, low-impact sandstone | Low impact toughness; prone to chipping in fractured rock |
| SR8C | 89.0 ± 0.5 | 2.0–3.0 | ≥ 2,200 | Mixed strata; general roadheader use | Lower wear resistance in highly abrasive, low-impact rock |
| SR10C | 88.0 ± 0.5 | 2.0–3.0 | ≥ 2,200 | High-impact, hard rock, boulder encounters | Highest wear rate; not suitable for abrasive-only applications |
SR7X is designed for maximum wear resistance. Its fine grain structure resists cobalt washout and abrasion, making it ideal for soft, abrasive coal seams or sandstone with minimal impact. In hard, fractured rock, SR7X may chip under impact loads that SR8C would survive.
SR8C offers a balanced profile. With a coarser grain and optimized cobalt content, it provides the toughness needed for typical roadheader operations while maintaining sufficient wear resistance. It is the default starting point for most tunneling applications.
SR10C prioritizes toughness. It is used when impact loads are extreme, such as in hard rock tunneling or when encountering boulders. The trade-off is higher wear rate, which is acceptable if tip loss is the primary concern.
Which Grade to Use — and Under What Conditions
The choice depends on the specific geological conditions of your tunneling project. There is no single “best” grade, only the best grade for your current face conditions.
Scenario A: High Abrasion, Low Impact
If your tunnel face consists of soft, abrasive rock like sandstone or shale with few hard inclusions, wear is the primary failure mode. SR7X is the correct choice. Its HRA 91.0 hardness ensures maximum tip life against abrasion.
Scenario B: Mixed Strata, Moderate Impact
For most roadheader applications, the rock face varies between abrasive and hard, with intermittent impact from harder layers. SR8C is the standard recommendation. Its 2.0–3.0 µm grain size provides the necessary toughness to resist chipping, while its HRA 89.0 offers adequate wear resistance. Ruixin SR8C at HRA 89.0 and 2–3 µm grain is the industry standard for balanced roadheader performance.
Scenario C: High Impact, Hard Rock
If you are tunneling through hard, fractured rock or encountering frequent boulders, impact toughness is critical. SR10C is the appropriate grade. Its high cobalt content absorbs the shock loads, preventing tip fracture. While it wears faster, it stays attached to the pick body, ensuring consistent cutting performance.
Because roadheader picks experience interrupted cutting and variable rock hardness, a grade with >10% cobalt is often necessary to absorb impact. SR8C at 10% cobalt and 2–3 µm grain is the standard starting point for most roadheader applications.
What Happens When You Choose the Wrong Carbide Grade
Selecting the wrong grade has direct operational and financial consequences. Understanding these risks helps justify the investment in proper grade selection.
1. Catastrophic Tip Loss
Using a hard, brittle grade (like SR7X) in high-impact conditions leads to chipping or complete tip loss. A lost tip requires replacement and can damage the pick body, leading to costly repairs or replacement of the entire pick. Tip loss events can increase maintenance downtime by 30–50%.
2. Excessive Wear Rate
Using a tough, soft grade (like SR10C) in abrasive conditions leads to rapid wear. The tip wears down quickly, reducing cutting efficiency and requiring more frequent replacements. This can increase the cost per meter advanced by 20–35% compared to using the correct grade.
3. Thermal Cracking
Incorrect grade selection can exacerbate thermal cracking. If the grade cannot withstand the heat generated by friction, micro-cracks form on the tip surface. These cracks propagate under impact, leading to premature failure. Ruixin SR8C at HRA 89.0 and 8% cobalt resists thermal cracking in medium-hard limestone at sustained cutting temperatures above 600°C.
4. Inconsistent Performance
Using a grade that is not optimized for the specific application leads to inconsistent tool life. This makes it difficult to plan maintenance schedules and manage inventory. Consistent grade selection ensures predictable tool life and reliable production rates.
How to Implement This in Your Operation
Implementing the correct carbide grade selection strategy requires a systematic approach. Start by analyzing your current failure modes. Are tips wearing down evenly (wear-dominated) or chipping and fracturing (impact-dominated)?
Step 1: Assess Rock Conditions
Document the rock type, abrasiveness, and impact frequency. Use geological surveys and core samples to determine the Cerchar Abrasivity Index (CAI) and Uniaxial Compressive Strength (UCS).
Step 2: Select Initial Grade
Based on the assessment, select an initial grade from the table above. For mixed strata, start with SR8C. For abrasive rock, start with SR7X. For high impact, start with SR10C.
Step 3: Monitor and Adjust
Track tool life and failure modes. If tips are chipping, move to a tougher grade (e.g., SR8C to SR10C). If tips are wearing too fast, move to a harder grade (e.g., SR8C to SR7X).
Step 4: Optimize with Custom Grades
If standard grades do not meet your requirements, consider custom grade formulation. Ruixin offers custom grade development based on specific application data. Send your application details — rock type, machine model, and current grade — and our engineers will confirm grade selection and available dimensions within 24 hours.
For roadheader picks, we recommend SR8C as the starting point for most tunneling applications due to its balanced properties. However, for highly abrasive conditions, consider our SR7X grade, available as coal tooth carbide tips and roadheader picks. For high-impact applications, explore our SR10C options.
Get a Custom Grade Recommendation
Selecting the right roadheader picks carbide grade is critical for operational efficiency and cost control. Ruixin provides expert technical support to help you optimize your tooling.
Send us your application details — rock type, machine model, and current grade specifications — and our engineers will confirm grade selection and available dimensions within 24 hours.
Contact Ruixin Tungsten Carbide:
– Email: info@ruixintungstencarbide.com
– WhatsApp: +86-15253178777
– Website: ruixintungstencarbide.com
We manufacture in-house with 14,200㎡ of production floor and up to 500 tons annual capacity. Our ISO-certified facility ensures consistent quality and batch reliability for global procurement teams.
English 
Russian 
Spanish 
French